Email This Page

*Denotes are mandatory fields.

Your Name : *
Your Email : *
Friend's Email : *
Friend's Name : *
Page URL : *
Message : *
Enter Captcha : *

Try another one


Sending Mail Please Wait ...

A prolific use of the ‘cut-copy-paste’ function by a Judge should not become a substitute for substantive reasoning which is the defining feature of the judicial process - Supreme Court   Mar 08, 2021

Deprecating the manner in which the High Court disposed off a Petition against the order of a Tribunal, the Supreme Court observed as follows:

"Cutting, copying and pasting from the judgment of the Tribunal, which is placed in issue before the High Court, may add to the volume of the judgment. The size of judicial output does not necessarily correlate to a reasoned analysis of thecore issues in a case. Technology enables judges to bring speed, efficiency and accuracy to judicial work. But a prolific use of the ‘cut-copy-paste’ function should not become a substitute for substantive reasoning which, in the ultimate analysis, is the defining feature of the judicial process. Judges are indeed hard pressed for time, faced with burgeoning vacancies and large case-loads.

Crisp reasoning is perhaps the answer. Doing what the High Court has done in the present case presents a veneer of judicial reasoning, bereft of the substance which constitutes the heart of the judicial process. Reasons constitute the soul of a judicial decision. Without them one is left with a shell. The shell provides neither solace nor satisfaction to the litigant. We are constrained to make these observations since what we have encountered in this case is no longer an isolated aberration. This has become a recurring phenomenon. 

The National Judicial Academy will do well to take this up. How judges communicate in their judgments is a defining characteristic of the judicial process. While it is important to keep an eye on the statistics on disposal, there is a higher value involved. The quality of justice brings legitimacy to the judiciary.

Copy of the judgement is attached   



No Poll Created

Name : *
Email : *
Comment : *

(Max characters allowed 522.)
File Upload :

Try another one

Enter Captcha Code*